Raport • Board Game Arena

Toate rapoartele

rapoarte pentru Wingspan

#72244: "Wrong score eggs and bonus cards at the end of the game"

notabug: Acesta nu este un bug

Despre ce este vorba acest raport?

Wingspan #301703440

Ce s-a întâmplat? Te rugăm alege de mai jos

Reguli: o regulă a jocului nu a fost respectată

Ce s-a întâmplat? Te rugăm alege de mai jos

Reguli: o regulă a jocului nu a fost respectată

Verificați dacă există deja un raport privind același subiect

Dacă da, te rugăm VOTEAZĂ pentru acest raport. Rapoartele cu cele mai multe voturi au PRIORITATE!

#	Status	Votes	Game	Type	Title	Last update

Descriere detaliată

Raportează istoric

20 Sep 2022 21:38 • mathicafael • Defectul nu a fost replicat încă de programatori:

20 Sep 2022 23:59 • paramesis • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

I can confirm the bonus cards were scored correctly.

Wetland scientist - 3 birds that can only live in wetland = 3 points
Viticulturalist - 4 birds that eat fruit = 7 points
Falconer - 1 bird with a predator power = 2 points

Did you happen to take a screenshot at the end of the game? It's possible there was a discrepancy over the course of the game between the server and interface regarding the number of eggs. I counted 18 eggs on your board (scored 18), and only 9 on your opponent's board (scored 10). There is a javascript error during the replay, which is probably the cause of the discrepancy on your opponent's board, which I will investigate.

11 Oct 2022 17:19 • christrick • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

table #307474816
Les cartes bonus photographer et anatomist ne prennent pas toujours en considération la traduction en français, du coup des oiseaux ne sont pas comptés dans le score final.
Exemples :
Westerne tanager ... Piranga à tête rouge
red cockaded woopecker .... pic à face blanche
prothonotary warbler .... paruline orangée
chestnut collared longspur.... plectrophane à ventre noir

30 Jan 2023 06:28 • sevmachine • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

I had a similar situation, 8 eggs counting toward final goal, my opponent had 7 . goal was awarded to my opponent. all nests were same type

30 Jan 2023 06:29 • sevmachine • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

you can look at the final situation of our game. Scored incorrectly changing it form a tie to an incorrect victory

30 Jan 2023 19:41 • paramesis • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

@mathicafael - I have been able to reproduce the display issue I could see in the replay regarding your opponent's number of eggs. It is the same issue as boardgamearena.com/bug?id=74072

There is another issue where the interface will appear to allow certain actions out of turn leading to display discrepancies and downstream script errors, reported here: boardgamearena.com/bug?id=76872
I haven't been able to reproduce anything of the sort with the replay of this table to affect your total number of eggs.

Both of these issues will be fixed in the upcoming version.

@christrick - This is a completely separate issue. Language dependent bonus cards are based on the English names of the birds. See boardgamearena.com/bug?id=69812

@sevmachine - I would need a table number to look at your game.

8 Feb 2023 16:56 • HeartsKing • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

Table 344972441.
F5 removes the scoring pad.
I did take a screen print: imgur.com/a/HlzoEjO
I count 19 tucked cards in the wildlife preserve but the scorepad indicates 18.

8 Feb 2023 17:17 • paramesis • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

@SuicideKing - Thank you for the table number and screenshot.

It looks like a display issue with the number of cards tucked behind the Yellow-Rumped Warbler. In the notification log for the game, I count 4 times that a card was tucked behind this bird, so the total of 18 is correct. After playing the entire replay, I see 4 on the bird at the end of the game as opposed to 5 in the screenshot, so this looks like something happened with notifications (minimized or separate tab, maybe). I'll see if I can reproduce the issue.

17 Feb 2023 17:17 • Stasinka • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

I had a similar problem. I didn't receive any points for my grain bonus card even though I had laid cards that had the grain on it.

Table #348035806
Move #287
Progression 100%

8 Mar 2023 17:56 • ruthless1000 • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

I had a similar problem with a bonus card. “Birds who eat berries” According to the rules the multicolored symbol on a bird (the one that indicates you can use any type of food to fulfill that requirement) counts towards these bonus cards. Including those birds, I had enough birds to award me the higher point value on the bonus card, but was scored at the lower point value.

8 Mar 2023 18:31 • paramesis • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

@Stasinka - You needed at least 5 birds with a grain symbol in order to meet the first threshold for the "Bird Feeder" bonus card and you only had 4.

@ruthless1000 the rules do not say that wild symbols count toward specific food types on bonus cards, only that any type of food token can be used when playing the bird. The cards themselves indicate that qualifying birds must have the symbol associated with that food type. Wilds do not count toward these bonus cards.

See also boardgamegeek.com/thread/2131903/article/31216925#31216925

6 Apr 2023 18:11 • fancypantz • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

In game number 364257828 this happened.

At the end of the game, samsoulsinger was scored for the final goal in 2nd place and tied with fancypantz. This is incorrect. Fancypantz had 4 sets of eggs, and samsoulsinger had 2 sets of eggs.

16 Apr 2023 05:28 • bookman01 • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

Also at scoring for # of birds with at least one egg, my game didn’t give me credit for 9 birds with eggs. boardgamearena.com/8/wingspan?table=367505419

16 Apr 2023 19:09 • archipelagos • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

got 5 birds on Trees for card Objective 8 points for 5 in trees
The Game didn t count 5 but only 4 ....

16 Apr 2023 19:29 • paramesis • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

@fancypantz - not a bug, as reported in boardgamearena.com/bug?id=85628
@bookman01 - the goal only counts birds with eggs in bowl nests, not all birds with eggs

I will not review issues added to this report that do not include a table number.

24 May 2023 01:28 • treeen • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

happened in my gamet too 380141006

25 Jun 2023 01:03 • Fortuna • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

See the end result of table 390443367.
My opponent got awarded 10 eggs in the final count, but they have 9, so this is incorrect.

14 Jul 2023 09:09 • jorgechapu • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

#394815923 I had 2 objective cards, one didn't give me points even I had enough birds that eat cereals to complete the first part of the quest
The other one worked correctly

1 Aug 2023 23:21 • RuthBe • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

Table #392707180
Move #265

i needed to be first because i have 3 egges on a bal bird and the other player has 2.

1 Sep 2023 20:02 • megsb2022 • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

I did not have my bonus card counted. I had bird feeder card and had birds that eat grain but I got 0 points for it.

2 Sep 2023 03:35 • Quincy2110 • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

End of bonus round two, score miscalculated for number of eggs in each habitat

7 Oct 2023 16:40 • RantingAndRaven • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

My bonus cards were not scored correctly. I had 5 birds with colors in the name, and it only recorded 3 birds with colors in the name, giving me fewer points at the end of game than I was entitled to.

14 Oct 2023 01:25 • RedCorsar • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

4th and last Mission - most eggs on forrest: I had 10 eggs on the forrest as well as my green opponent - still he's on first place, I'm on 2nd place. As per my understanding not correct.

Table ID #427877917
Zug #288
Fortschritt 100%

27 Oct 2023 18:25 • IndAmy • Dezvoltatorii cer mai multe informaţii pentru a reproduce această eroare:

imgur.com/a/YOwegv0

I had 5 birds in the wetland habitat which should have given me 7 points not the 3 I was actually given. This combined with another bug cost me the game.

27 Dec 2023 06:31 • paramesis • Acesta nu este un bug:

The specific display errors noted in my earlier comments on this report have been fixed. These involved players showing the wrong number of eggs and were not strictly related to end of round scoring or bonus cards. Since these are addressed in other reports, and to underscore the point below, I am marking this as not a bug.

Since the stable release in September 2022, none of the hundreds of bug reports I have received challenging goal board or bonus card scores has ever proven there to be a bug with the logic of how these scores are calculated. All of these come down to misinterpretations of clearly documented rules. I simply cannot spend any more time chasing down comments with just a table and round number (sometimes not even that).

If you believe there is a bug with how a goal or a bonus card was calculated, please review all of the rules surrounding this issue carefully before making a report.

Adaugă ceva la acest raport

Adăugați aici ceva care pare relevant pentru a reproduce acest bug sau pentru a înțelege sugestia dvs.:

Alt identificator de masă / de mutare
A rezolvat F5 problema?
Această problemă a apărut de mai multe ori? De fiecare dată? Ocazional?
Dacă ai o captură de ecran cu acest bug (ceea ce îți sugerăm), poți folosi Imgur.com pentru încărcarea imaginii și pentru a pune link-ul aici.

Renunţă Actualizează raportul

#72244: "Wrong score eggs and bonus cards at the end of the game"

Despre ce este vorba acest raport?

Ce s-a întâmplat? Te rugăm alege de mai jos

Ce s-a întâmplat? Te rugăm alege de mai jos

Verificați dacă există deja un raport privind același subiect

Descriere detaliată

Raportează istoric

Adaugă ceva la acest raport

Schimbă statusul raportului în:

Ajutor

Contribuie

Navighează

Urmărește-ne